HOLLYWOODBest Medicine Review: Josh Charles in Fox Doc Martin Remake

Best Medicine Review: Josh Charles in Fox Doc Martin Remake

Josh Charles made his name playing smooth, confident types like Will Gardner on The Good Wife. In FOX’s Best Medicine, he plays almost the exact opposite: a gifted surgeon with zero bedside manner who would rather be left alone than make small talk. The show is FOX’s American take on the long-running British comedy Doc Martin, and after a big January 2026 launch, it is now well into its second season.

Here is our review, plus a guide to the cast and where to watch.

Advertisement

What is Best Medicine about?

Charles plays Dr. Martin Best, a brilliant Boston surgeon who walks away from his big-city career to become the general practitioner in Port Wenn, Maine. It’s the fishing village where he spent childhood summers, and it is full of nosy, eccentric locals he has no patience for.

There is a twist, too. Martin has developed a phobia that makes surgery impossible: he can’t stand the sight of blood. That secret hangs over everything he does, even as he gets pulled into the lives of the townspeople he keeps trying to avoid.

The series was adapted by showrunner Liz Tuccillo, who also executive produces alongside Ben Silverman, Howard T. Owens and Rodney Ferrell, plus Doc Martin producers Mark Crowdy and Philippa Braithwaite. It premiered on Sunday, January 4, 2026, before settling into its regular Tuesday 8 p.m. slot.

Josh Charles is the reason to watch

Playing a man who is rude to almost everyone could easily turn grating over 13 episodes. Charles avoids that by underplaying it. His Martin is blunt and impatient, but you can always see something going on underneath, whether it’s embarrassment, loneliness or fear.

The A.V. Club’s Brian Tallerico put it well, writing that Charles “is great at playing guys who try to swallow their emotions.” Even lukewarm critics agreed the lead performance holds the show together.

Advertisement

The supporting cast of Port Wenn

The main players in Port Wenn include:

  • Abigail Spencer as Louisa Gavin, the local schoolteacher and Martin’s on-again, off-again romantic interest
  • Annie Potts as Aunt Sarah, Martin’s aunt and one of the few people who can get through to him
  • Josh Segarra as Sheriff Mark Mylow
  • Cree as Elaine Denton
  • Jason Veasey as George Brady and Stephen Spinella as Greg Garrison, both promoted to series regulars for season 2
  • John DiMaggio and Carter Shimp as father and son Bert and Al Large

Spencer is the standout here. She and Charles share an easy, low-key chemistry that gives the slow-burn romance real weight. Potts is a warm presence, though several reviewers felt she was underused in season 1. Season 2 adds more complications for Martin, with Eliza Coupe’s Dr. Eden Montgomery forming one side of a love triangle with Louisa.

Best Medicine vs. Doc Martin

Doc Martin starred Martin Clunes as a grumpy London surgeon who moves to the Cornish village of Portwenn after developing a fear of blood. It ran on ITV for ten series, from 2004 to 2022.

The bones of the story are the same in Best Medicine. The big change is the setting. Cornwall becomes coastal Maine, and the British reserve gives way to a more American kind of small-town quirk. The show was shot in the Hudson Valley, with towns like Beacon, Cornwall, New Hamburg and Hudson standing in for Port Wenn and the Hudson River playing the harbor.

Fans of the original will also spot a nice nod: Martin Clunes himself shows up as a special guest star, playing Dr. Robert Best.

Advertisement

Reviews, ratings and season 2 status

Critics were mixed to positive. The show holds a Metacritic score of 60, which counts as “mixed or average.” Fans of the show called it comfort TV. Detractors felt the supporting characters were too broad and the quirkiness too loud.

Audiences were far less divided. The premiere reportedly drew 12.6 million viewers, and FOX renewed the show for a second season in early March 2026, before season 1 had even finished airing. FOX Television Network president Michael Thorn called it “a breakout for us this season.”

Season 2 debuted with a special early premiere on Sunday, September 20, 2026, then returned to Tuesdays at 8/7c on September 22. The new season runs 14 episodes, one more than season 1. There is no word yet on a season 3.

For more network medical drama news, read our latest on Grey’s Anatomy season 23 and its Texas spinoff.

Where to watch Best Medicine

New season 2 episodes air Tuesdays at 8 p.m. ET/PT on FOX and stream the next day on Hulu. All 13 episodes of season 1 are on Hulu, and they also landed on Netflix in the U.S. on August 4, 2026, which helped the show find a new audience over the summer. For critic scores and episode reviews, see the show’s page on Rotten Tomatoes.

Our verdict: Best Medicine won’t reinvent the medical show, and it isn’t trying to. It is a gentle, funny hour built around a very good lead performance, and Doc Martin fans should give it a shot. For more streaming picks, browse our TV and OTT coverage.

Best Medicine quick facts

  • Network: FOX
  • Premiere: January 4, 2026
  • Based on: ITV’s Doc Martin (2004–2022)
  • Showrunner: Liz Tuccillo
  • Star: Josh Charles as Dr. Martin Best
  • Setting: Fictional Port Wenn, Maine
  • Episodes: 13 in season 1, 14 in season 2
  • Status: Season 2 airing now; season 3 not yet announced
  • Streaming: Hulu (next day); season 1 also on Netflix in the U.S.

About the author

Daya Nanoskar

Daya Nanoskar

Daya Nanoskar is an Entertainment Writer at Awesome TV and a contributor to AWSM Times. Daya covers film news, streaming releases, celebrity updates and industry news across Hollywood and Bollywood, and has written more than 2,300 stories for Awesome TV. Story tips and corrections: hello@awesometv.com.

Our editorial policy

Where to Watch / Shop

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Awesome TV earns from qualifying purchases. Links below are affiliate links.

Watch on Amazon

🎬

Get Bollywood & OTT Updates in Your Inbox

Join 2M+ South Asians worldwide. Weekly Bollywood, celebrity news & streaming picks — free.