Veteran Producer Says Netflix Films Are Trapped in a ‘Closed System,’ Warns Cannes and Venice Could Miss Cinema’s Future

The veteran Hollywood producer, best known for bringing Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me to the screen, has criticized streaming’s growing influence on cinema and urged major film festivals to protect the art of filmmaking.

As he prepares to receive a lifetime achievement award at the 2026 Locarno Film Festival, Sighvatsson reflected on an industry undergoing rapid change. Despite the rise of streaming platforms, he argued that theatrical exhibition remains essential to the movie experience.

Sighvatsson acknowledged Netflix’s ability to finance ambitious projects. However, he questioned whether films that debut on the platform can achieve the same cultural impact as theatrical releases.

He described Netflix as a “closed system” where films remain largely confined to subscribers instead of becoming shared cultural experiences. Although streaming offers convenience and worldwide access, Sighvatsson believes cinema creates its greatest impact when audiences experience stories together on the big screen.

The producer also criticized major film festivals for shifting their focus toward large-scale productions. He argued that festivals such as Cannes and Venice should continue championing independent filmmakers and original storytelling instead of prioritizing blockbuster premieres and celebrity-driven events.

According to Sighvatsson, festivals must strike the right balance between commercial success and artistic discovery to ensure the long-term future of international cinema.

He also addressed the growing role of artificial intelligence in filmmaking. While he accepted that AI will reshape parts of the production process, he insisted that filmmakers should use the technology as a creative tool rather than a substitute for human talent.

Sighvatsson emphasized that imagination, emotion, and unique artistic vision remain at the heart of filmmaking—qualities that technology cannot replace.

Throughout his career, Sighvatsson has worked with acclaimed directors including David Lynch, Ang Lee, Kathryn Bigelow, and Curtis Hanson. His productions have earned critical acclaim and multiple Academy Awards, helping shape modern independent and prestige cinema.

As Locarno honors his decades-long career, Sighvatsson remains optimistic about the future of filmmaking. However, he believes the industry must continue investing in theatrical releases, independent filmmakers, and original storytelling while embracing technological innovation responsibly.